Asphalt Shingles vs. Metallic Roofing – Which One is for You

When you are getting ready to install a new roof, you might wonder what the best material might be!

Photos By: Stock Images

You want to be mindful of your budget but also keep safety in mind. Appearance matters, too – because you want your roof to match the style of your home. 

Asphalt roofs have been the most popular choice for a long time because they are dependable, reasonably priced, and easy to care for. But you could consider other types of material- including metal roofing (the second most popular type of roofing.) 

Both materials have their good and bad points, so it may be good to compare them to each other. . Most of today’s roofing materials can be fashioned to mimic slate, tile, and wood. You can find scalloped edges or the appearance of terra cotta.

Metal roofs were first made in corrugated tin panels. This look was fine for barns and farm roofs but did not mesh with more contemporary housing styles. Since metal roofs have now evolved and can be shaped and designed to mimic other styles, it is better to be choosing roofing for your home based on how it will perform for you (rather than its appearance.) 


In general, metal roofs are more durable. They can withstand most weather challenges and often come with 30-50 year warranties. However, they are not without weaknesses. Metal roofs could be damaged by heavy hail or by falling branches,. As a rule of thumb, steel is more vulnerable than copper. 

Asphalt has a shorter endurance. The asphalt can develop fungus when water pools in the creases or corners. Ice buildup can create cracks in the roof.. If the temperature in your area switches too quickly between hot and cold, it can shorten the roof’s life. Asphalt roofs come with a 15-30 year warranty. 


Asphalt is less expensive than metal roofs. Asphalt prices will be $100-$200 per 100 square feet. Metal roofs will cost from $120-$900 per 100 square feet. Metal roofs will also have a higher installation cost since they require a specialized procedure. 

Even though you will pay more for the metal roof upfront, you will not be as likely to need to replace it. You will also save money on your energy bill due to metal’s ability to retain temperature. Some homeowners’ insurance companies will offer you a discount for having a metal roof. You may even qualify for a tax credit. 


Metal roofs are considered more sustainable because their materials can be recycled repeatedly. Metal shingles have reflective qualities and keep excess heat from being transmitted inside the home. Special paints can be added to the metal roofing materials to decrease your heating bills further. Asphalt shingles need to be replaced more frequently. Asphalt is also made of petroleum, leading to fossil fuel dependence. 

Ease of Installation and Repair

Asphalt is easier to install. It can be installed with basic tools, and working with asphalt does not take special training. Metal roof installation usually requires special training and special tools. Some lighter metal roofs can be installed directly over an existing roof (as long as the original remains in good condition). 

Asphalt can also be easier for fixing your roof than metal. It may not be wise to do the job yourself – (that might void the homeowners’ insurance warranty), but asphalt is generally easier to work with. 

If you’re looking for a professional roofing contractor, the trained staff at Elite Services And Roofing will help you with all of your ogden roof repairs that you stand in need of!

Leave a comment